The inSocialWork Podcast
Skip to Content
Mother and child speaking with a social worker in a home setting.

Fifty Years of CAPTA, the Poverty It Never Named and the Urgency for Redesign

Play episode

“We do not have a social support network; we have a social surveillance network, where you have to apply to receive support and services.”

Mary McCarthy, PhD

How did a law that was created to protect children from abuse develop into a system that focuses more on investigating families than providing them with the support they need? In our latest episode, Mary McCarthy, PhD, explores how the child welfare system has changed since the Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act (CAPTA) passed in 1974.

McCarthy explains how poverty plays a significant role in child welfare cases, particularly when it comes to neglect. Although poverty alone is not considered neglect under New York State law, families experiencing financial difficulties can still find themselves involved in child protective investigations. She discusses how unclear definitions of neglect and mandated reporting requirements can lead to families being investigated rather than connected with resources.

Throughout the conversation, McCarthy discusses the importance of rethinking how the child welfare system responds to families in need. Drawing on her work with New York’s Western Child Welfare Citizen Review Panel, she shares recommendations to improve the system by providing greater transparency, better screening of reports, stronger legal representation for parents and a greater focus on outcomes for families. She encourages listeners to consider how the system can move away from investigating poverty and toward providing families with the resources and support they need.

Mary McCarthy

Mary McCarthy, PhD, MSW, is faculty emeritus at the University at Albany School of Social Welfare. She has worked in child welfare since 1973, beginning her career shortly before CAPTA passed. Her experience includes child protective work in Onondaga County, New York. She serves on New York’s Western Child Welfare Citizen Review Panel, where she contributes to discussions and recommendations focused on improving child welfare policies and practices.

Show Notes

Cite this podcast – Lee, J, & Sage, T. (Hosts). (2026, November 17). Fifty Years of CAPTA, the Poverty It Never Named and the Urgency for Redesign. (No. 354) [Audio podcast episode]. In inSocialWork. University at Buffalo School of Social Work.

Join the discussion

More from this show

The inSocialWork Podcast